How to Prep a Cigar

Prepping a cigar isn’t about following some overly complicated ritual—it’s about giving your cigar the respect it deserves, so that when you light up, the smoke is smooth, the aroma is full, and the flavor comes through exactly as the cigar makers intended.

Whether you’re pulling something rare from your humidor or trying cigars for the first time, the preparation process matters. From choosing the right cigar cutters to lighting with care, the way you prep has a noticeable impact on draw, burn, and overall enjoyment.

Here’s a breakdown of what you need, what to avoid, and how to enjoy your cigar the way it was meant to be smoked.

Step 1 - Start With the Right Tools

Before you do anything else, make sure you’ve got the basics covered. You don’t need a pile of gear—just a few reliable tools and accessories go a long way in keeping your prep simple and effective.

Here’s what you’ll need:

• Cigar Cutter: For making a clean, precise cut that ensures proper airflow, no matter what cigar shape you're working with
• Cigar Lighter: Preferably a butane torch or soft flame lighter for even, flavor-neutral lighting
• Humidor: To maintain optimal humidity levels and preserve the cigar’s freshness over time

These are your starting points. A good cigar cutter helps you avoid tight draws or unraveling wrappers. 

At Renegade Cigars, we recommend using a modern double-bladed cutter for cutting cigars—it delivers a clean, balanced slice from both sides of the cap, reducing the chance of crushing or tearing the wrapper. While some smokers enjoy the traditional feel of cigar scissors, double-bladed cutters offer greater consistency, precision, and ease, especially for those newer to cigar prep.

Meanwhile, the right lighter gives you clean, reliable ignition from the first draw, setting the tone for an even, enjoyable smoke.

Not sure where to begin? We’ve made it easy with our most trusted selections. Explore our handpicked cigars for beginners and well-seasoned smokers alike.

Step 2 - Learn How to Cut a Cigar Properly

CHECK PRICE

Every cigar is sealed at the head with a cap made from the same leaf as the cigar wrapper. Your job during cigar cutting is to remove just enough of that cap to create an open, consistent draw, without going too deep and causing the wrapper to unravel.

A bad cut can lead to uneven burning, fraying, or restricted airflow—none of which do the cigar (or your experience) any favors. A clean, well-placed cut allows proper airflow while preserving the integrity of the tobacco and wrapper.

To cut a cigar properly, aim to remove around 1/16 to 1/8 inch, just before the cap line. Any deeper, and you risk damaging the structure of the cigar. The draw should feel smooth and natural, not tight or overly airy.

Here’s a quick comparison of popular cigar cutters and how they work for various types:

Cutter Type	Cut Style	Best For	Pros	Cons
Guillotine	Straight cut	Most cigar sizes	Versatile, clean, full draw	Risk of overcutting if not done carefully
V-Cutter	V-shaped wedge cut	Medium to large ring gauges	Enhances draw, concentrates flavor	Requires precision, not ideal for smaller, tapered cigars
Punch Cutter	Circular hole in cap	Small to medium ring gauges	Preserves cap and wrapper, easy to use	Limited airflow, not suitable for all cigars

Guillotine cutters come in single-bladed or double-bladed designs. A double-blade typically offers a more balanced slice, but a high-quality single-bladed cutter can still deliver a precise cut if kept sharp and used with care

No matter what you prefer—guillotine, V-cutter, punch, or even cigar scissors—a sharp blade is the most important detail. Dull tools can crush, leading to frayed wrappers and a ruined drawer.

With any style, aim just above the shoulder—the spot where the curved end begins to level into the body of the cigar. That’s your target.

Pro-Tip: Cut your cigar just before you smoke it. Cutting too early lets the tobacco dry out, which dulls the flavor. And if you’re new to cigar cutting, practice with cheaper sticks until you’ve nailed your technique.

Step 3 - Light the Cigar the Right Way

Lighting a cigar takes a bit of focus. Rushing this step can lead to a harsh or uneven burn, scorched cigar wrapper, or tunneling straight down the center, which can seriously impact flavor and enjoyment. 

Whether you're just getting into smoking cigars or you're dialing in your technique, taking time to light properly is one of the easiest ways to elevate your experience. Let’s take a quick look at how to do this right:

Choose the Right Lighter

CHECK PRICE

Lighting a premium cigar isn’t the same as lighting up just anything. Unlike cigarettes, a cigar is built for slow enjoyment, from the precise cut to the first puff filled with rich aroma.

Use a quality Renegade torch lighter for a strong, consistent flame. It’s dependable and burns clean, so it won’t interfere with the flavors crafted by expert cigar makers. 

Soft flame lighters or cigar-specific wooden matches work too, but they’re less reliable in breezy conditions. Avoid candles or cheap lighters with impure fuel—they can taint the tobacco and cause uneven burns.

Toast the Foot of the Cigar

Start by holding the end of the cigar (the foot) at a 45-degree angle with the flame just nearby—never directly touching. 

Slowly rotate the cigar to toast the edge of the tobacco filler. This outer layer, or wrapper leaf, will begin to darken and glow slightly. 

The goal is an even light around the entire edge, which warms up the filler leaves and gets them ready to burn properly.

Light While Drawing

Once the foot is toasted, place the cigar's head (the capped end you cut with your cigar cutters) gently in your mouth. Bring the flame back toward the foot and take a few measured draws while continuing to rotate. A balanced start helps develop that smooth cigar smoke and ensures the cigar burns cleanly through to the end.

Take Your Time

Take it slow. Rushing leads to scorching, an uneven burn, or tunneling, where the center burns faster than the edge. 

Starting properly sets the tone for the entire experience, especially if it's your first cigar or you’re trying something new.

Done right, lighting a good cigar is part of the ritual. You’ll notice the difference from that very first draw.

Step 4 - Storing Cigars the Right Way

Tobacco is highly sensitive to humidity and temperature, so proper storage is non-negotiable. Cracked wrappers, bitter flavors, or burn problems often trace back to poor storage.

Cigars are best stored in an environment similar to where they were aged—around 65% to 72% relative humidity and about 70°F (21°C). If cigars dry out, they burn hot and lose nuanced flavor. If they’re too moist, they develop tight draws, muted taste, and in worst cases, mold.

Proper storage matters no matter the brand or the origin—Cuban cigars, Nicaraguan blends, or Dominican favorites all benefit from climate consistency. Every few weeks, rotate your cigars so they age evenly.

Before using a brand-new humidor, season it by wiping it with distilled water and leaving it closed with a humidity source for several days. Add your cigars only when conditions are stable.

Travel humidors, like the Aganorsa Loaded Travel Humidor, are useful for keeping cigars in good condition while in transit.

Don’t leave storage to chance. Explore our humidors and Boveda humidity control packs trusted by cigar collectors across the country.

Did You Know? The ideal storage environment mimics the tropical climate where premium tobacco is grown—around 65–72% relative humidity and approximately 70°F (21°C).

Avoiding Common Mistakes in Prepping Cigars

Even the finest cigars can lead to a frustrating experience if mishandled, especially during preparation. From using the wrong cigar cutters to rushing the light, these small missteps can affect everything from flavor to draw. Fortunately, they’re easy to avoid with a little care and attention.

Overcutting

One of the quickest ways to ruin a cigar is by cutting too far into the cap. The cap serves as a seal and keeps the wrapper leaf intact. Go too far, and the wrapper can start to unravel before you even finish your first third.

To avoid this, look for the faint crease where the cap ends at the curved end of the cigar. Make a clean, confident cut just above that line to create a smooth opening. 

This is especially important on traditionally shaped cigars, where too much precision is lost with an aggressive cut.

Using a V-cut, also known as a wedge cut, is a great option for those wanting a deeper draw without risking wrapper damage, particularly on thicker cigars. Alternatively, a well-made pair of cigar scissors offers a bit more control for those who prefer an old-school method.

Uneven Burning

Seeing one side of your cigar burn while the other struggles to stay lit? That’s what we call canoeing. This usually happens when the cigar wasn’t lit evenly to begin with, or if someone’s puffing too quickly, or smoking in windy conditions. 

During the smoke, rotate the cigar every few draws and keep your pace steady. If one side seems to lag behind, don’t panic—just touch it up lightly with your flame to keep things on track.

If you’re constantly dealing with uneven burns or airflow issues, it might be due to a plugged cigar, which often results from poor construction or rough handling. Gently rolling the cigar between your fingers before lighting can help loosen any tight spots.

Pro-Tip: Never inhale the smoke! Cigars aren't inhaled like cigarettes. Take slow draws, hold the smoke in your mouth to savor it, then let it go.

Using the Wrong Flame Source

Lighting a cigar with a standard gas station lighter or candle can introduce unwanted flavors to your cigar smoke due to chemical residues in the fuel. That’s not how your cigar was meant to taste.

Always use a clean butane torch or soft flame lighter to preserve the blend’s integrity and get an even, controlled burn.

Improper Storage

CHECK PRICE

Cigars are sensitive to temperature and humidity fluctuations. Storing them without a humidor—or in a poorly maintained one—can lead to bitterness, cracking, or mold on your cigar. 

By avoiding these common missteps, you’ll preserve cigar integrity and ensure every stick delivers on its full potential. Every detail—from the cut to the final draw—contributes to the overall enjoyment.

Keep It Simple, But Do It Right

Cigars don’t ask for much—just a bit of care. With the right prep, your entire experience becomes smoother, more flavorful, and easier to enjoy from the very first draw to the last bit of cigar smoke.

Take the time to make a clean cut. Light with patience. Store your cigars like they matter—because they do.

If you’re getting ready for your first cigar or looking to try something new, we’re always here to help. No fluff, no upselling—just solid recommendations and good cigars from people who know and care.

Ready to light up something great? Explore our full collection at Renegade Cigars and grab your next favorite smoke.