Cigar Reviews

Based on 727 reviews
92%
(669)
6%
(43)
1%
(9)
1%
(5)
0%
(1)
Arturo Fuente Magnum R Rosado Sungrown

Very nice cigar for the price. Smokes mild and is full bodied.
I will continue to purchase this cigar.

Room 101 Farce Connecticut

This is one of my mid morning top choices. Smooth, buttery, lots of smoke but not heavy. Woody with a hint of creaminess

Perfect morning stick

Corona had a great draw, thick smoke, and even burn. Creamy, leathery, graham cracker flavor in a quick, enjoyable smoke. Paired with coffee with heavy cream and honey. Perfect morning combo.

more please sir!

Great taste, too bad such a limited production run.

Rocky Patel Perfect Timing

I really like these smokes. They offer a smooth and even draw with a nice full-bodied flavor without being too dark or rich for an afternoon smoke. This is one of my regular purchases at Renegade, and I am never disappointed.

Knockabout

Average smoke. Had some restrictions in smoking last time. Will be smoking another one today.hHopefully a better smoke.

Great customer service! Love the monster!! Joined the cigar club too! Can't wait to try some new sticks!

T
Oliva Serie V Melanio
Troy McKinney

Great draw, great flavor

Papas Fritas

Very smooth quick and enjoyable. Prefect for 20-30 minute smoke.

R
Rare Fuente Sampler
RICHARD Hester
Love those Fuentes

Top four where the Rare Pink(too short for my preference), Opus oscuro, Casa Robustos(best of the entire lot) and the Reserva No. 60 - all five stars. The rest were okay -four stars or less. Was value for money.

J
CAO Eileen's Dream
Jason Sulzbach
Great

I was worried these were going to be just a candy cigar. But it was smooth and mild, with that background of Irish cream that made it very satisfying. Finishing clean.

C
Plasencia Alma Fuerte
Chris Crihfield
A+ Smoke Every Time

I like to grab a few of these throughout the year, sometimes for special occasion, sometimes just to treat myself. One of those that you can just trust to be exactly what you’re expecting every time.

Recently picked up 2 that are sitting in the humidor for thanksgiving with my pops. Great smoke and highly recommend.

Blue Eyed Jack

This cigar is the best in the ADV line. I have smoked multiple sizes, and they all perform well. The Blue-Eyed Jack cold be a morning or afternoon cigar. I am getting plenty of smoke with tastes of creaminess + pepper. I highly recommend.

C
Oliva Serie V
Curlee Hudson
smooth and complex

this is one of the easiest to smoke cigars I've experienced. the cigar has some complex favors to go with it smoothness.

M
CLE Corojo
Mark Wilkinson
CLE Corojo

Great value in a light to medium cigar. Bought box for a party and it was good fit for most everyone.

M
Padron 1926
Mark Wilkinson
Padron 1926

Nice easy draw, even burn, stays lit. Medium with great flavor.

Great smoke

Excellent cigar

The 11th anniversary has been my favorite Cigar so far. I need to have the 14th side-by-side with it because I may have a new favorite. In the end, all the collaborations and anniversary Cigars have been excellent.

Fantastic Cigar!!

For the past 4 years now I've gotten to enjoy Renegade's Anniversary cigar and this is the second time I've scored a full box. And boy am I glad I did. This cigar is fantastic and I've loved the first 2 I've smoked. Be sure to enjoy the cold draw as its quite special and once lit, the cigar has a delicious, peppery retrohale that is excellent. Great job guys!!

My favorite cigar released this year.

Great lighter. Have two of them

One of my favorite go tos

a little sweet and nicely complex, a great combo

Rocky Patel 15th nice smoke

Always a good smoke. Well balanced and very enjoyable

Solid

Graham, some pepper, vanilla, cream. Lighter cigar with lots of smoke output. Never a tight draw. Awesome short, light-med smoke with some flavor.

D
ARFCOM Cigar
Dave Dayter
Love the Cigar

Love the cigar. Has a perfect balance of flavor . Definitely going to buy as many as I can while you still have them.